Reversible and Irreversible Changes — Answers
Answer sheet with model answers and success criteria for the 3rd Grade states of matter & materials worksheet.
Reversible and Irreversible Changes — Answers
Part A: Can it be undone?
Read the passage. Then circle the best answer.
Materials can change when we heat them, cool them, mix them or change their shape.
A reversible change can be undone. Melting, freezing, dissolving and changing shape are usually reversible. Ice can melt into water, and the water can be frozen into ice again.
An irreversible change cannot be undone. A new material is made. Cooking, baking and burning are irreversible. A baked cake can never turn back into flour, eggs and milk.
Signs of an irreversible change include a new color, a new smell, bubbles of gas, smoke or ash.
- Aburning paper
- Bmelting butter
- Cbaking bread
- Dfrying an egg
Answer: melting butter
Melted butter can be cooled to become solid again.
- Afreezing juice
- Bmelting ice
- Ctoasting bread
- Ddissolving salt in water
Answer: toasting bread
Toast can never be turned back into soft bread. A new material has formed.
- AFreeze it.
- BLet the water evaporate.
- CStir it more.
- DAdd more water.
Answer: Let the water evaporate.
When the water evaporates, the salt is left behind. Dissolving is reversible.
- AThe material changes shape.
- BThe material melts.
- CSmoke, ash or a new smell is made.
- DThe material gets colder.
Answer: Smoke, ash or a new smell is made.
Burning makes smoke and ash, which are new materials. This shows an irreversible change.
- Airreversible, because it is a new material
- Breversible, because it is still chocolate
- Cirreversible, because it was heated
- Dnot a change at all
Answer: reversible, because it is still chocolate
Melting and freezing (setting) only change the state. It is still chocolate and can be melted again.
Part B: Sort and explain
- freezing water into ice
- burning a log
- squashing play dough
- boiling an egg
- irreversible
- reversible
- reversible
- irreversible
Answer: freezing water into ice → reversible; burning a log → irreversible; squashing play dough → reversible; boiling an egg → irreversible
Answer: reversible
Answer: ash
Answer: Heating the mixture makes a new material (cake). You cannot get the flour, eggs and milk back.
Part C: True or false?
Write True or False.
Answer: True
Cooling the liquid turns it back into a solid.
Answer: False
Burning is irreversible; new materials have formed.
Answer: False
Heating ice melts it, which can be reversed. Some heating changes are reversible.
Answer: True
The sugar is left behind when the water evaporates.
Part D: Thinking scientifically: explain your claim
Model answer: I disagree. Melting candle wax is reversible: the liquid wax cools and becomes solid wax again. Burning the wick and wax is irreversible: it makes new materials such as smoke and gases, so the wax is used up and cannot come back.
Success criteria:
- States disagree
- Explains melting is reversible with a reason
- Explains burning is irreversible because new materials form
Marking tips
- Give credit for correct method even when the final answer slips — the working shows where the thinking went right.
- For open-ended tasks, use the success criteria as a checklist rather than looking for one "right" answer.
- Celebrate what went well first, then pick one thing to work on next.