Comparative Essays: Comparing Two Texts
A guide to the comparative essay for senior English, in which two texts are put in conversation about an idea. Using two original…
- Difficulty
- Level 3 · Challenge
- Time
- 35 min
A structured workshop in which students plan an analytical essay from an original prompt on an original short text, 'High Water', about a family after a flood. Tasks move from unpacking the question to writing a thesis, three topic sentences, selecting evidence with techniques, planning a conclusion and drafting a full introduction. Every task has a model answer, and the introduction task carries a marking rubric, so the method can be checked and then transferred to any HSC/VCE-style prescribed text.
Instant download · No sign-up · Free for personal, classroom and homeschool use
Curriculum: Australian Curriculum. We show specific outcome codes only where they have been verified against the official curriculum document.
Completed: Essay Planning Workshop
More resources for this topic are coming soon.
Year 12 students (typically ages 17–18) working on text analysis & essays. It is pitched at level 3 · challenge.
Yes. The PDF includes a full answer sheet with model answers and success criteria where there is more than one good answer. You can also view the answers online.
About 40 minutes for 12 questions. Short, regular sessions work best: two or three a week beats one long one.
No. Click Download Free PDF and it opens immediately. It is free for personal, classroom and homeschool use.
Explore more Year 12 english resources.
Year 12 · English · Text Analysis & Essays
Student name:
Date:
Score: /
Total: 34 marks. Suggested time: 40 minutes. A plan this detailed takes five minutes in an exam once the method is automatic.
Read the question first, then the text twice. Mark the moment the narrator's understanding changes, and the one object the text returns to.
Essay question: 'Change forces people to decide what they will hold on to.' Analyse how the composer represents the relationship between change and belonging in 'High Water'.
'High Water' (original short text, approx. 330 words)
The water had gone down a week ago but the line stayed. It ran around the inside of the house at the height of my shoulder, a brown tide-mark on every wall, through the kitchen, along the hall, across the photographs we had not got down in time.
Mum said we would paint over it when the walls dried. Dad said nothing, which was what he said about most things now. He spent the days at the shed with the pump, and the nights on the verandah with the radio, listening for the river the way other people listen for a baby.
I was the one who found the measuring. Every morning Mum took the tape to the lounge-room wall, to the line, and measured from the floor. One hundred and forty-one centimetres. She wrote it on the back of an envelope with the date, as if the line might be getting taller in the night, or shorter, as if the house were a child she was keeping track of.
'It's not going anywhere,' I told her.
'No,' she said. 'That's the point.'
I did not understand that then. I think I do now. In the weeks when everything moved, the furniture, the neighbours, the ground itself, she found the one thing in the house that would stay where it was, and she measured it, and it held.
We painted the walls in March. Two coats. You cannot see the line now unless you know where to look, and all of us know where to look, and none of us say so. Sometimes I see Mum rest her hand there, at shoulder height, passing through the hall, the way you would steady yourself on a wall in the dark.
How to use this workshop: work through the tasks in order. Each one produces a piece of the plan; by the end you will have a thesis, three topic sentences, selected evidence, a conclusion plan and a full introduction. If your teacher prefers, apply the same tasks to your prescribed text and a question from a past paper.
Complete each task in order. Marks are shown so you can see which parts of a plan carry the most weight.
Preview — the PDF contains the full resource and answer sheet.
A guide to the comparative essay for senior English, in which two texts are put in conversation about an idea. Using two original…
The skills that separate a good English exam result from a very good one: reading the command term accurately, unpacking the question,…
A practical method for the unseen-text section of senior English exams: a five-step first-read routine, what to look for in prose, poetry,…
Worksheet · Year 10 · Text Analysis & Essays · Level 3 · Challenge
Worksheet · Year 10 · Text Analysis & Essays · Level 3 · Challenge
Free to print and share for personal, classroom and homeschool use. Please don't resell. Spotted an error? Let us know.